A retrospective exploration of healthcare communication with adult siblings of individuals with Down syndrome over time
ACMG 2026
Madelyn Falk, Stephanie Santoro, Victoria Suslovitch
Introduction
Siblings of individuals with Down syndrome (DS) play significant roles in their siblings’ lives, providing support, companionship, and advocacy. However, the distinct experiences of siblings in healthcare settings remain unassessed, including the long-term impact of healthcare provider (HCP) communication. This study addresses this gap.
Methods
A mixed-methods survey of adult siblings of individuals with DS explored the frequency, duration, content, and perceived quality of HCP communication over the lifetime. The survey examined sibling understanding, the closeness of the sibling relationship, and sibling willingness to act as a caregiver in the future. Participants were recruited via the Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) Down Syndrome Program and local and national advocacy groups for DS (October-December 2024). Quantitative data were analyzed using Chi-Square, Fisher’s Exact, and ANOVA; qualitative data were thematically coded to identify insights.
Results
Participants included 104 siblings from 29 US states (mean age 36.1 years, range 18–66). Most participants identified as female (79%), White (87%), and not Hispanic or Latino (92%). Most participants were older than their sibling with DS (69%) (siblings with DS mean age 31.8 years, range 3–62).
At the time of sibling diagnosis, a family member often (85%) disclosed the diagnosis of DS to the participant. Notably, no HCPs disclosed the diagnosis. As the number of topics discussed during disclosure increased, participants’ understanding of DS and their sibling significantly increased (P<.0001 and P=.0401). However, comprehension plateaued with three or more topics, suggesting an optimal amount of information to facilitate understanding. Receiving more information lowered nervousness (P=.017), though excessive information reversed this trend, reflecting an emotional threshold in early communication.
Most participants (72%) never spoke to an HCP about DS during childhood or adolescence. When they did, conversations were rarely initiated by HCPs (18%). Among those who did engage with HCPs, higher communication quality was significantly associated with improved understanding. When providers explained things clearly and spent enough time with siblings, siblings were significantly more likely to agree they gained a greater understanding of DS (P=.0207 and P=.0076). These findings indicate that communication clarity and time investment are critical for promoting understanding during developmental years.
As adults, many participants (67%) reported having a conversation about DS with an HCP. As the number of topics discussed increased, participants’ understanding of both DS and their sibling also significantly increased (P=.0043 and P<.0001), with no evidence of the comprehension plateau seen during childhood. Higher-quality HCP communication, characterized by spending adequate time, listening carefully, showing respect, and explaining information clearly, was significantly associated with fewer remaining questions about DS (P=.0001, P=.0108, P=.0015, and P=.0209, respectively). This suggests thorough, empathetic, and bidirectional dialogue directly enhances sibling comprehension and reduces uncertainty in adulthood.
Despite improvements in communication over the lifetime, 43% of participants reported feeling excluded from HCP discussions. Many expressed a desire for more engagement and acknowledgment from HCPs. Notably, the sibling relationship was not significantly impacted by differences in HCP communication, suggesting the sibling relationship cannot easily be waivered. Lastly, the survey asked about participants’ current or future status as a caregiver for their sibling with DS. Most participants (81%) were not currently the full-time caregiver or legal guardian for their sibling, though many participants (86%) reported it is likely they will in the future.
Conclusion
This research highlights that HCP communication with siblings can be improved and offers insights into interventions to be implemented to better support siblings. Siblings’ unique role differs from that of typical caregivers or parents and can significantly affect involvement in their sibling’s care. Ensuring inclusion of siblings as integral members of the care team can strengthen family knowledge, promote shared decision-making, and improve continuity of care for individuals with DS.
Related publications